On Christmas Eve morning I received a package from my publisher Little, Brown. Inside that envelope was my manuscript in its stark copy-edited form.
What are copy edits, you ask? Oh, they are just the thing that forces you to stare into the abyss of your own incompetence. (Thanks to my friend, colleague and fellow writer David Bloom for that apt description.)
I’m not just talking grammar or typos here, people. Though my astoundingly thorough copy editor caught all of those and then some, it seems. I’m talking about every single, solitary, little detail that didn’t addd up in “The Mockingbirds.” Like how I originally wrote that the antagonist didn’t reside in the Brooks Hall dorm, but two chapters later he did. Like how, my main character’s roommate was sitting at her desk during a conversation and then two pages later mysteriously hopped up from her bed. And how about the fact that I referred to a certain location on campus with a nickname that made no sense out of context because I had forgotten I deleted the explanation of the nickname five pages before? (Note to fellow writers: when you delete scenes and paragraphs make sure other elements in the story don’t depend on them!)
Oh, there’s more, so much more. Things I can’t even tell you I did. Words I am too ashamed to admit I misspelled. Antiquated phrases I used.
But my biggest sin of all is this one.
It says: “How many days have passed? Timeline very hard to track t/o (throughout).”
And she was right. Because you could drive a hovercraft through the timeline gaps in my novel. After the linear pace of the first five chapters, I rarely mentioned what day it was or how many days had gone by. In fact, in chapter eleven I even wrote that a certain thing that happened at the close of the previous chapter happened both last night and last week. In the same chapter! I didn’t even catch the error.
And that’s why I bow down before my most capable copy editor for letting me stare into the abyss of my own incompetence (and rectify it) before the public can.

Get a Trackback link
1 Trackbacks/Pingbacks
12 Comments
This right here reassures me that even manuscripts accepted are not entirely flawless. Of course, this isn’t to say you shouldn’t try and make your manuscript flawless. It’s just to say that agents and/or editors aren’t going to slit your throats over an error and press reject a million times until their index fingers break from clicking the mouse so hard.
I have to tell you that I snorted coffee through my nose over this. Why would I find such amusement over something NOT amusing in the slightest for the writer? Because I FEEL it! I just went over the ms for my YA one more time after receiving a very supportive rejection from a prospective agent. He really liked my writing and thought my novel was destined to be published. He even told me to keep him in mind if I had other manuscripts. I was so thrilled that I read through it again, to bolster myself and my confidence in it…. and I started finding the goofs… the REALLY obvious ones… and I was mortified… so I fixed them… reminding myself that the agent liked my work even with these mistakes… that he thought it had great potential… even with these mistakes…
I just sent the YA ms out to another agent who asked for a full (!!!) And now I’m forbidding myself from reading it again… because I know that I’ll find something else… something small…. something really irritating…
I know this feeling, I just went over a book that my father is writing and there were so many times that I could tell that he had all these little parts in his head that just didn’t make it to, or were taken off, the paper. It is so hard to figure out when parts are missing, especially time line, because you know the whole story backwards and forwards.
That quote is perfect, “the abyss of your own incompetence” I will have to send this onto my dad.
Aren’t you thankful that your editor has your back? And just think, you sold your book WITH the errors! It’s going to be amazing, Daisy. I can’t wait to read it!!!!
Hi Daisy
Thank you for sharing!
Because of this post I have a new-found respect for the editorial process and renewed faith in my own writing.
Happy Holidays!
RKCharron
Wow, what a Xmas present! I’ve been waiting for my editor to return copy edits too, and it’s been like looking forward to a semi-excited, semi-dreaded gift every morning…
Good luck with yours!
I agree with RKCharron. I always struggle with perfection, knowing I’ll never achieve it. Your post shows everyone that not even the published are perfect, everyone makes mistakes, and even with those mistakes if our work is good we can achieve our dreams.
Thanks Daisy!
Daisy I’m ROFL at your expense. But you knew that, didn’t you? I mean, you put this out there not only for our edification but for our entertainment as well, right? ((hugs)) on the gaffs. Can’t wait to read your book!
OMG – this is too freaking funny! I mean not FUNNY funny, but SCARY funny. I know what’s coming down the pike… Should I run and hide now before the embarrassment and humiliation hits?
I’m not sure if I should be terrified or excited…maybe both? Can’t wait till we get to the copy edits stage in the game!
Lisa, Debra — just embrace it, I say! Nothing else you can do. I await your reports!
@daisy It’s not scheduled to come out till 2011 so I have some time (I think!)
Leave a comment